Using Values, Hope and Grit to Predict Academic Success and Retention in First Year Tertiary Study
Status
Completed: 8 August 2009
Project Details
A project, completed in 2009, to identify relationships between important personal values, hope and grit (perseverance), and with retention and success in first year tertiary study. A collaboration of The Open Polytechnic of New Zealand and University of Canterbury.
Aims:
The main aims of the project were to:
- identify values that predict success and retention in first year tertiary students
- identify if personal values, hope or grit (perseverance) predicted retention or success in first year tertiary students
- dentify a practical action-orientated solution for enhancing teaching effectiveness in order to increase success and retention rates.
Methodology:
The project methodology involved:
- an online questionnaire survey administered to two sets of first year students
- matching the survey results with students’ retention rates and academic grades.
Team
Aaron Jarden
Project Leader
The Open Polytechnic of New ZealandAlexander Mackenzie
University of CanterburyStatus
Funding
$5,790.00 (excl GST)
Key Findings
The key findings from the project included:
- Older students complete less; yet score higher when they do complete.
- Females and distance education students complete less; yet score similar to males and contact education students when they do complete.
- There are distinctly different personal values and grit profiles between distance and contact education students that can be utilised to enhance teaching effectiveness, in particular by increasing success and retention rates. Distance students may benefit from motivational strategies that tap into self-enhancement values and promote ambition. Contact students may benefit from motivational strategies that tap into conservative values and reinforce effort.
- All students may benefit from identifying what is important (i.e., personal values) and taking steps to live in alignment with their values, and from having their interest in study consistently engaged.
- Hope does not seem to be related to retention or success in first year tertiary study
- Of note, the characteristic of grit (perseverance) was a stronger predictor of both retention and success in first year tertiary study than originally thought (and to a lesser extent values and, minimally, levels of hope).
Key Recommendations
The key recommendations from the project included:
Identifying students who may need more intervention | The Grit Scale in particular enables a quick and effective identification of students who may need more intervention in order to succeed (this could take many formats and may include more phone or in-person contact, more motivational material, etc). This ability to target support may further improve students’ experience of their first year of tertiary study.
Further research into the Grit Scale | The Grit Scale should be further investigated and utilised, with more concrete norms and cut scores developed on larger and specific student populations. This 12 (or 17) item scale is quick to administer and score; and has the potential to provide much benefit to a teacher. In the absences of concrete cut scores and norms related to retention and success, this scale can be used to rank groups of students from high to low levels of grit for targeting.
A poster prepared by Aaron Jarden.
(PDF, 1.5 MB, 1-pages).
- 20 August 2009